
KEA Just Says NO to AI
No AI Declaration
I’m really happy to see the pushback against AI data centers and that it’s become an issue in the November elections. Voters realize the impact data centers have on their local power grid and water supplies, and are saying Not in my city, not in my county! What concerns me, though, is what I don’t hear. What I don’t hear is people connecting their personal use of AI with the need for that data center. My point is, you cannot truly be against data centers if you use AI! To help me make my point, let me start with the basics.
What is AI?
AI is software that has the capability to learn, solve problems, and make decisions, which are tasks usually associated with human intelligence. I didn’t understand what this meant until I saw a YouTube video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nwx96e7qck0 that showed how AI learned to play the old Breakout video game. Breakout is an early Atari game in which a player uses a paddle to bounce a ball off bricks in a brick wall. The ball magically makes the brick disappear to make points. AI was not told the object or rules of the game but was asked to score the most points it could. It took AI about an hour of trial and error to learn the object and the rules of the game, and another hour to improve play until it was better than any human. AI learned and then excelled!
How you interface with AI is through a chatbot, which is software designed to simulate human conversation and is the AI/human interface.ChatGPT and Google Gemini are the two largest.AI “Agents,” like Devin or Cursor, perform more complicated tasks like writing or testing software code. Honestly, I don’t use a chatbot or an AI Agent, so I cannot say much about either. People I know who do use AI tell me that it is a valuable workplace tool. I’ve also heard lots of criticism when these tools are used by students to shortcut the educational process or result in self-harm by the user.
Where do the data centers come in?
This is where I do have some personal experience. Before retiring, I spent years coming up with ways to deploy and protect high-speed internet (HSI) electronics for Nokia. Yes, Nokia phones disappeared long ago, but Nokia continued to sell HSI electronics to customers like ATT and Verizon. Electronics needs to be powered, cooled, and protected from the weather, and most of my career was spent matching electronics to cabinets that met those needs. Fortunately, the cabinets I worked with were usually small enough to fit in neighborhoods between the street and sidewalk and were cooled with fans.
The companies installing data centers have a business plan that says that use of AI will continue to grow exponentially and that to support that growth, bigger is better! One driver for the “bigger is better” approach is the power required by AI. The International Energy Agency states that a query made to ChatGPT consumes 10 times the electricity of a Google search! This increase in power demand is what drives data centers to stress local power grids, and the more power electronics consume, the hotter the electronics get. Data centers cannot cool their electronics with cooling fans as I could. They require a huge amount of water to provide that cooling.
No AI Declaration
While the potential for AI to advance solutions for the environment and our society is great, the negative environmental impacts are equally staggering. Until the infrastructure required to support AI can be built without threatening local power grids, water supplies, and communities, any statement, any research, or post made by KEA will be made by humans, not by AI.
We encourage anyone to ask themselves, “Do I really need AI to find this information, or will a simple search engine get me the result I need? Choose conservation over convenience, and the future health of our natural, shared resources will thank you.
***For current data regarding the impacts on natural resources (water and energy), we encourage you to further read these peer-reviewed reports published by The National Institute For Water Resources.
